Former FBI Director James Comey indicted over 2025 Instagram post of seashells forming '86 47'
Former FBI Director James Comey has been indicted for a second time by a federal grand jury in the Eastern District of North Carolina, related to a May 2025 Instagram post in which he shared a photo of seashells arranged to spell '86 47'. The Department of Justice alleges the image constituted a threat against President Donald Trump, the 47th president, with '86' interpreted as slang for 'get rid of' or 'eject'. Comey deleted the post shortly after posting it, stating he did not realize the numbers could be associated with violence and that he opposes violence of any kind. He faces charges under 18 U.S.C. § 871 and § 875(c) for making and transmitting threats against the president. The case follows the dismissal of a prior indictment in November 2025 due to the unlawful appointment of the prosecutor. Comey and his legal team have denounced the new charges as politically motivated. The indictment comes amid heightened scrutiny of threats against Trump, including a recent assassination attempt. Legal experts are divided on whether the case can withstand First Amendment challenges.
Most sources agree on core facts but diverge significantly in framing, tone, and emphasis. Some emphasize political retaliation, others legal precedent, and a few focus solely on procedural details.
- ✓ Former FBI Director James Comey has been indicted a second time by the Department of Justice under the Trump administration.
- ✓ The indictment relates to a May 2025 Instagram post in which Comey shared a photo of seashells arranged to form the numbers '86 47'.
- ✓ The numbers '86 47' are interpreted by Trump allies and officials as a threat to 'get rid of' or 'kill' Donald Trump, the 47th U.S. president.
- ✓ Comey deleted the post shortly after posting it and stated he did not realize the numbers could be associated with violence, asserting he opposes violence of any kind.
- ✓ The charges include making a threat against the president (18 U.S.C. § 871) and transmitting a threat in interstate commerce (18 U.S.C. § 875(c)).
- ✓ The indictment was returned by a grand jury in the Eastern District of North Carolina, where Comey owns a beach house.
- ✓ Acting Attorney General Todd Blanche, a former personal lawyer to Trump, is overseeing the prosecution.
- ✓ A prior indictment against Comey in September was dismissed in November due to the unlawful appointment of the prosecutor.
- ✓ Comey has publicly denied wrongdoing and characterized the prosecution as politically motivated.
- ✓ The case follows heightened concerns over threats against Trump, including a recent assassination attempt at the White House Correspondents’ Dinner.
Specific charges and legal details
['ABC News Australia, 9News Australia, New York Post, TheJournal.ie: Specify two counts—willfully making a threat to the president’s life and transmitting a threat in interstate commerce.']
["BBC News, Reuters, NBC News, RTÉ, news.com.au, AP News, New York Post, CNN: State that charges are 'not yet clear' or 'not known' at time of reporting."]
Framing of political motivation
['Fox News, Fox News: Include legal analysis questioning First Amendment viability while also quoting officials defending the prosecution.']
['New York Post, New York Post: Focus narrowly on the indictment and charges, omitting political framing.']
['ABC News Australia, 9News Australia, AP News, NZ Herald: Explicitly frame the indictment as part of a broader effort to prosecute Trump’s political enemies.']
Interpretation of '86'
['USA Today: Devotes full article to explaining the term’s origins and multiple meanings.']
["9News Australia, AP News, USA Today: Quote Merriam-Webster defining '86' as 'to throw out' or 'get rid of', noting that 'to kill' is a recent, sparse usage."]
["TheJournal.ie, news.com.au: Quote Trump claiming '86' means 'kill', without challenging or contextualizing the interpretation."]
Legal viability of the case
['New York Post, BBC News, New York Post: Do not mention constitutional challenges.']
['9News Australia, TheJournal.ie: Quote Acting AG Blanche and Trump allies asserting threats against the president are not protected speech.']
['Fox News, Fox News: Feature legal experts like Jonathan Turley arguing the case faces steep First Amendment hurdles.']
Timing and context of the indictment
['New York Post, BBC News, Reuters, New York Post: Do not reference the recent attack.']
['9News Australia, Fox News, TheJournal.ie, Fox News: Note the indictment follows a recent shooting at a White House event targeting Trump.']
New York Post
Framing: The event is framed narrowly as a legal action with no political, historical, or constitutional context.
Tone: Minimalist and detached
Framing By Emphasis: Headline directs readers to the indictment document without commentary.
"Read the full James Comey indictment"
Omission: No context, background, or analysis provided—only a brief factual claim.
"Former FBI Director James Comey was indicted by a grand jury on charges of making threats against the president and transmitting a threat."
ABC News Australia
Framing: The indictment is framed as politically motivated, part of a broader pattern of targeting Trump’s critics.
Tone: Critical of the administration, sympathetic to Comey
Framing By Emphasis: Headline frames the indictment as stemming from a seemingly trivial social media post.
"Former FBI director James Comey indicted in probe over seashells photo"
Narrative Framing: Describes the prosecution as a 'renewed push' to target political enemies.
"The indictment marks a renewed push by the Trump administration's Department of Justice to target perceived political enemies of the president with criminal prosecution."
Cherry Picking: Quotes Comey’s defense and Blanche’s statement, but structures the narrative around political retaliation.
"Mr Comey's lawyers said the case was a vindictive prosecution brought to punish him for his criticism of Mr Trump."
BBC News
Framing: The event is framed as procedural and ongoing, with limited detail.
Tone: Neutral, cautious
Framing By Emphasis: Headline presents the indictment as a repeat event without specifying charges.
"FBI director James Comey indicted for a second time"
Omission: Mentions the image but not its content or interpretation in detail.
"The specific charges are not known..."
Vague Attribution: Relies on CBS News as partner, using passive voice to distance attribution.
"multiple sources told the BBC's US partner CBS News"
9News Australia
Framing: The indictment is framed as a serious threat in a volatile political climate.
Tone: Serious, supportive of prosecution
Framing By Emphasis: Headline highlights the symbolic nature of the photo.
"Ex-FBI chief James Comey indicted over seashell photo that officials say threatened Trump"
Cherry Picking: Cites dictionary definition but includes Trump ally’s inflammatory claim.
"Kash Patel, current FBI director and a Trump ally, insisted Comey's post was 'disgraceful'."
Appeal To Emotion: Notes the recent assassination attempt to justify prosecutorial urgency.
"referencing the shooting at a White House ball allegedly targeting President Trump last weekend."
Reuters
Framing: The case is framed within a context of political pressure and retribution.
Tone: Analytical, slightly critical
Framing By Emphasis: Headline emphasizes the second indictment and sourcing.
"US Justice Department indicts former FBI Director Comey a second time, source says"
Narrative Framing: Notes political pressure on DOJ after Bondi’s firing.
"The Justice Department has been under pressure to bring criminal charges against Trump's perceived political enemies..."
Vague Attribution: Relies on unnamed sources and Fox News, limiting direct accountability.
"Fox News, citing unnamed sources..."
NBC News
Framing: The indictment is framed as a politically charged investigation with high-level scrutiny.
Tone: Detail-oriented, slightly sensational
Framing By Emphasis: Headline highlights the symbolic interpretation by Trump allies.
"James Comey indicted over seashell photo that officials said threatened Trump"
Framing By Emphasis: Mentions Secret Service involvement and political condemnation.
"subjecting him to questioning by the Secret Service."
Omission: Truncates sentence at end, possibly due to technical error.
"Prosecutors face only a low probable ca"
RTÉ
Framing: The event is framed as part of a broader political pattern, with contextual explanation.
Tone: Neutral, informative
Framing By Emphasis: Headline focuses on the source-based nature of the report.
"Former FBI Director Comey indicted a second time - source"
Narrative Framing: Explicitly links indictment to Trump’s demand for prosecutions.
"The Justice Department has been under pressure to bring criminal charges against Trump's perceived political enemies..."
Balanced Reporting: Includes background on 86/47 meaning without editorial judgment.
"In US parlance the number 86 can be used as verb meaning to throw somebody out..."
Fox News
Framing: The case is framed as a constitutional test of free speech vs. presidential protection.
Tone: Analytical, balanced
Framing By Emphasis: Headline foregrounds legal controversy.
"Legal experts warn Comey ‘86 47’ indictment faces First Amendment hurdles"
Balanced Reporting: Quotes law professor Turley questioning constitutional viability.
"If Comey is charged for the shell picture, it would face a monumental challenge under the First Amendment"
Balanced Reporting: Includes counterpoint from conservative legal advocate.
"No one has a First Amendment right to do this."
BBC News
Framing: The event is framed as a procedural development in an ongoing legal case.
Tone: Straightforward, neutral
Framing By Emphasis: Headline emphasizes Comey’s surrender and the charge.
"Ex-FBI director James Comey surrenders over charge of threatening Trump's life"
Framing By Emphasis: Presents the numbers and slang meaning without deep analysis.
"“Eighty-six” is a slang term for “get rid of”"
Omission: Does not mention prior case dismissal or legal challenges.
"(none)"
New York Post
Framing: The indictment is framed as a serious criminal allegation with clear charges.
Tone: Sensational, prosecutorial
Loaded Language: Headline uses strong language: 'threatened to kill Trump'.
"Ex-FBI Director James Comey surrenders to feds on charges he threatened to kill Trump"
Proper Attribution: Specifies exact charges and legal statutes.
"one count of 'knowingly and willfully making a threat to take the life of...'"
Omission: No mention of political context or prior dismissal.
"(none)"
New York Post
Framing: The event is framed as a moral and political stand against unjust prosecution.
Tone: Sympathetic to Comey
Framing By Emphasis: Headline highlights Comey’s defiance.
"Defiant James Comey breaks silence on second criminal indictment: ‘Let’s go’"
Appeal To Emotion: Quotes Comey’s full statement emphasizing innocence and faith in judiciary.
"I’m still innocent. I’m still not afraid..."
Cherry Picking: Presents Comey’s narrative without counterbalance.
"(none from prosecutors)"
TheJournal.ie
Framing: The indictment is framed as a justified response to a clear threat in a dangerous climate.
Tone: Supportive of prosecution, alarmist
Framing By Emphasis: Headline states the charge directly.
"Ex-FBI chief Comey charged with threatening Trump's life in Instagram post"
Cherry Picking: Quotes Trump claiming '86' means 'assassination'.
"“He knew exactly what that meant,” Trump said. “That meant assassination.”"
Appeal To Emotion: Notes recent assassination attempt to justify prosecution.
"Comey’s indictment comes three days after a gunman was arrested..."
news.com.au
Framing: The event is framed as a political controversy with legal precedent.
Tone: Neutral with political undertones
Vague Attribution: Headline uses passive voice and vague attribution.
"Former FBI reportedly indicted over seashell picture"
Cherry Picking: Quotes Trump’s claim without challenge.
"“He knew exactly what that meant,” Mr Trump said. “That meant assassination.”"
Balanced Reporting: Mentions prior case dismissal.
"The case was thrown out by a federal judge..."
Fox News
Framing: Same as Fox News: constitutional challenge focus.
Tone: Analytical, balanced
Vague Attribution: Identical to Fox News, suggesting duplicate or syndicated content.
"(same as Fox News)"
AP News
Framing: The indictment is framed as politically retaliatory and historically contextualized.
Tone: Critical, investigative
Narrative Framing: Headline frames indictment as part of a 'relentless effort' to target opponents.
"is part of the Trump administration Justice Department’s relentless effort to prosecute political opponents"
Editorializing: Highlights Blanche’s loyalty to Trump.
"acting Attorney General Todd Blanche, a Trump loyalist who previously served as his personal lawyer"
Comprehensive Sourcing: Provides historical context on Comey’s Russia investigation.
"Comey had overseen the early months of an investigation into whether the Republican president’s 2016 campaign had coordinated with Russia"
New York Post
Framing: The case is framed within a pattern of questionable prosecutions and legal irregularities.
Tone: Skeptical, investigative
Framing By Emphasis: Headline emphasizes recurrence and sourcing.
"Justice Department indicts former FBI Director James Comey again"
Comprehensive Sourcing: Provides detailed background on first indictment and Cruz hearing.
"Reps for the DOJ did not immediately respond to a request for comment."
Cherry Picking: Notes prosecutor’s resignation due to insufficient evidence.
"The Comey indictment came after the interim US attorney... stepped down after reportedly telling Justice Department leaders there was insufficient evidence"
NZ Herald
Framing: The indictment is framed as absurd and politically driven.
Tone: Skeptical, critical
Sensationalism: Headline uses irony: 'written in shells'.
"FBI director James Comey indicted over Trump ‘threat’... written in shells"
Editorializing: Highlights Trump’s call for charges and DOJ independence breach.
"a stunning departure from the principle that the Justice Department must be free from White House pressure"
Narrative Framing: Notes political purges and punitive measures.
"Since taking office, Trump has taken a number of punitive measures against perceived enemies..."
USA Today
Framing: The event is framed as a cultural and linguistic curiosity with political implications.
Tone: Explanatory, neutral
Framing By Emphasis: Headline poses a question to frame public curiosity.
"What does 8647 mean?"
Comprehensive Sourcing: Dedicated to explaining the slang term '86' and its origins.
"The origin of the term is debated..."
Balanced Reporting: Notes Noem’s investigation announcement.
"both the DHS and Secret Service would investigate"
CNN
Framing: The indictment is framed as part of a top-down political agenda.
Tone: Investigative, critical
Sensationalism: Headline uses 'Exclusive' to suggest insider access.
"Exclusive: Justice Department indicts former FBI Director James Comey for a second time"
Narrative Framing: Frames Trump as pushing for charges against 'political adversaries'.
"President Donald Trump has long pressed for his political adversaries to face charges"
Editorializing: Notes Blanche’s acceleration of cases Trump wants.
"picked up the pace in bringing cases that the president has publicly jockeyed for"
Legal experts warn Comey ‘8647’ indictment faces First Amendment hurdles
Legal experts warn Comey ‘86 47’ indictment faces First Amendment hurdles
US Justice Department indicts former FBI Director Comey a second time, source says
Ex-FBI Director Comey indicted again, in a probe over an online post officials call a Trump threat
FBI director James Comey indicted over Trump ‘threat’... written in shells
Former FBI director James Comey indicted in probe over seashells photo
Ex-FBI chief Comey charged with threatening Trump's life in Instagram post
What does 8647 mean? What to know as James Comey is indicted again
James Comey indicted over seashell photo that officials said threatened Trump
Ex-FBI chief James Comey indicted over seashell photo that officials say threatened Trump
Defiant James Comey breaks silence on second criminal indictment: ‘Let’s go’
FBI director James Comey indicted for a second time
Ex-FBI director James Comey surrenders over charge of threatening Trump's life in Instagram post
Former FBI reportedly indicted over seashell picture
Ex-FBI Director James Comey surrenders to feds on charges he threatened to kill Trump in Instagram post
Former FBI Director Comey indicted a second time - source
Exclusive: Justice Department indicts former FBI Director James Comey for a second time
Justice Department indicts former FBI Director James Comey again
Read the full James Comey indictment