Big Tech
Date Range
Score Range
NZ Herald (Effective / Failing) : How to plan a massacre: AI bots told scientists how to make biological weapons
Tech companies are portrayed as failing to adequately safeguard their AI models
The article notes that safety guardrails were added but deemed 'insufficient,' implying corporate negligence or inadequate response to known risks.
“The company added some safety guardrails to the product after his testing, he said, though he felt they were insufficient.”
The Guardian (Ally / Adversary) : Raise tax on alcohol and junk food to cut deaths from liver disease, experts say
Framing digital platforms as adversaries in promoting unhealthy products to minors
The article criticizes online advertising targeting under-18s, implicating digital platforms in public health harm, though not naming them directly.
“stop under-18s being targeted with online advertisements for alcoholic drinks and junk food”
The New York Times (Effective / Failing) : The Split Between China and Silicon Valley Just Got Wider
framed as constrained by geopolitical forces in global expansion
[editorializing] language like 'clean breakout' implies lost opportunity due to external interference, subtly framing Big Tech’s ambitions as thwarted
“It looked like a clean breakout from China’s crowded, tightly regulated market and a path to the world stage.”
CBC (Trustworthy / Corrupt) : Should B.C. ban or regulate social media and AI for youth?
Big Tech (via OpenAI) framed as failing in duty of care and accountability
[loaded_language], [omission]
“OpenAI CEO Sam Altman wrote an apology letter to the community for failing to alert the RCMP about the shooter's account”
The Guardian (Trustworthy / Corrupt) : Google reportedly signs classified AI deal with US Pentagon
Framed as ethically compromised by military collaboration
[loaded_language] and [appeal_to_emotion] highlight moral unease among employees, suggesting Big Tech's integrity is under question despite corporate justifications.
“employees’ fears that their work could be used in “inhumane or extremely harmful ways””
New York Post (Trustworthy / Corrupt) : AI chatbots terrify scientists with ‘chilling’ instructions on how to build biological weapons: report
Tech companies are portrayed as insufficiently accountable for AI risks
While corporate responses are included, the article emphasizes expert concern and downplays the effectiveness of company safeguards, implying negligence or inadequate action.
“Relman said the company, which couldn’t be named due to a confidentiality agreement, made changes to address his concerns, though he felt they weren’t enough to ensure public safety.”
NBC News (Ally / Adversary) : Pentagon inks deal with Google for AI services
Framed as a cooperative partner with the U.S. military
[framing_by_emphasis] and selective sourcing elevate institutional collaboration while downplaying internal dissent
“The Pentagon and Google have reached an agreement for the Defense Department to use the tech company’s powerful Gemini AI systems on classified networks, according to a U.S. official familiar with the deal.”
Fox News (Legitimate / Illegitimate) : Kimmel seizes on Trump's old age joke during meeting with King Charles, jokes he 'should …
Broadcast media legitimacy questioned through regulatory threat
Misleading context frames Disney/ABC's license review as politically motivated punishment rather than routine procedure, undermining institutional legitimacy.
“Eight Disney-owned ABC affiliates will have to prove to FCC Chairman Brendan Carr that they have been operating in the public interest.”
The Guardian (Trustworthy / Corrupt) : France launches probe into website that enabled mass rape of Gisèle Pelicot
digital platforms are portrayed as inherently dangerous and complicit in enabling organized sexual violence
The article links the website to multiple severe crimes and highlights its cross-border operation and re-emergence, implying systemic failure or unwillingness of tech platforms and regulators to prevent abuse.
“Authorities say the French-language platform Coco has been linked to crimes, including the sexual abuse of children, rape and murder”
BBC News (Trustworthy / Corrupt) : France investigates reappearance of website tied to Pelicot crimes
implies tech platforms are complicit or negligent in hosting predatory content
[loaded_language], [narrative_framing]
“platforms that hosted them bore responsibility, as did those who created them”