Religion
Date Range
Score Range
The Guardian (Legitimate / Illegitimate) : Crewe religious group raided by police investigating allegations of serious sexual offences
Portraying the religious group as inherently illegitimate through ridicule of beliefs
[editorializing]
“AROPL is a sect that blends tenets of Islam with conspiracy theories about the Illuminati and aliens controlling US presidents.”
Fox News (Safe / Threatened) : Viral TikTok trend of teens running through Scientology buildings sparks hate crime allegations
Religious spaces portrayed as under threat from online-driven youth stunts
The article emphasizes the intrusion into religious facilities using emotionally charged language and highlights injuries and chaos, framing the Church as vulnerable and under attack.
“Over recent weeks, individuals have repeatedly forced their way into Church properties on Hollywood Boulevard, disrupted religious and public facilities, damaged Church property, and endangered staff, parishioners and visitors”
New York Post (Beneficial / Harmful) : Jaden Ivey posts photo with wife after accusing her of abandoning him in middle of …
Religion is framed as a redemptive and positive force in personal crisis
[appeal_to_emotion] - The inclusion of religious language and framing, particularly the Bible verse and expressions of divine salvation, emotionally positions religion as a healing and morally affirming presence in the couple's reconciliation.
“Thank you Jesus for saving us. Thank you for your mercy and goodness towards us.”
The Guardian (Trustworthy / Corrupt) : Camp Mystic director says ‘we tried our hardest’ in deadly flood: ‘It wasn’t enough to …
Christian camp leadership questioned on moral accountability and stewardship
Patriarchal framing of leadership and emotional apology imply moral failure in religious duty of care
“Investigators described the late camp director, Richard Eastland, as a patriarch deficient in planning”
Daily Mail (Legitimate / Illegitimate) : Chilling recordings emerge revealing heart-wrenching new details after acupuncturist mom killed her two adorable children
Spirituality portrayed as a dangerous, cult-like influence leading to violence
The article selectively highlights the suspect’s spiritual interests and labels them a 'cult-like obsession', implying a causal link between non-mainstream belief systems and criminal behavior without evidence.
“A professional acupuncturist, MacAusland made her cult-like obsession with spirituality clear online, writing in her Instagram bio: 'Surfing waves of the Zuvuya. Counting sleeps 'til enlightenment.'”
Fox News (Included / Excluded) : Judge orders Washington school district to loosen limits on off-campus Bible club for public school …
Religious expression portrayed as systematically excluded in public schools
The article emphasizes policies that allegedly marginalize religious materials and activities, such as hiding Bibles and exclusion from flyers, framing them as acts of exclusion.
“forcing students to keep any LifeWise materials, including Bibles, hidden in envelopes in their backpacks”
CBC (Ally / Adversary) : No 'blanket immunity' for historical charges against former private Christian school teachers: Sask. regulator
Religious institution is framed as adversarial through implication of interference in legal testimony
[vague_attribution]: The mention of the church pastor influencing testimony is presented without full sourcing, implying institutional misconduct while relying on prior internal reporting, potentially framing the religious entity as complicit.
“CBC previously reported that Beaudry and her daughter said they were encouraged by their church pastor to initially tell police the sexual assault conduct by the athletic director began when the girl was 16, to make it easier on him, rather than the truth that it began when she was younger than 16.”
The Guardian (Effective / Failing) : The pope’s African tour shows the continent is vital to the future of Catholicism
Catholic Church portrayed as spiritually revitalized through African engagement
[comprehensive_sourcing]: The article cites demographic growth and spiritual leadership from Africa as renewing forces for global Catholicism, implying institutional effectiveness through southern vitality.
“The growing centrality of Africa and its Black diaspora for pastoral practice... should be viewed in terms of a potential to influence the evangelisation of the world.”
The Washington Post (Legitimate / Illegitimate) : Alleged gunman at correspondents’ dinner was deeply Christian in college
Religious justification for violence is framed as a dangerous misinterpretation, undermining the legitimacy of such theological reasoning
[loaded_language], [cherry_picking]
“Allen’s screed seemed to center on "enemy elimination."”
The New York Times (Legitimate / Illegitimate) : Epstein Obtained Objects From Islam’s Holiest Site for His Island ‘Mosque’
Religion is framed as being violated or disrespected through misuse of sacred objects
[sensationalism], [loaded_language], [omission]
“Epstein Obtained Objects From Islam’s Holiest Site for His Island ‘Mosque’”