Indigenous Peoples
Date Range
Score Range
CTV News (Included / Excluded) : Feds outline $4.3B for Indigenous education, health in spring economic update
Framing Indigenous communities as included and prioritized in national policy
[framing_by_emphasis] The article highlights substantial federal funding directed at Indigenous education, health, housing, and child welfare, emphasizing inclusion and targeted support.
“The federal government is promising $4.3 billion for First Nations education, Inuit food security and Indigenous child welfare in its spring economic update.”
CBC (Included / Excluded) : James Poker aged out of a treatment centre at 16. Nobody told his father
Indigenous child and community framed as excluded from care decisions and cultural continuity
[framing_by_emphasis] on cultural disconnection and removal from kinship; omission of institutional justification
“None of this would have happened if James had remained with his family and community”
news.com.au (Included / Excluded) : ‘Critical time’: Minister’s ominous nuclear warning as US looks to resume tests
Framed as historically wronged and deserving of protection from nuclear harm
The reference to Maralinga and its 'lingering effect on the Indigenous community' serves to humanize the anti-testing stance by invoking past injustice. This positions Indigenous people as victims of nuclear testing and implicitly calls for their inclusion in moral considerations around nuclear policy. The framing is positive but reactive, emphasizing past exclusion to justify current safeguards.
“We know Maralinga (the UK’s 1950s nuclear weapons testing site in Australia) had a lingering effect on the Indigenous community.”
CBC (Included / Excluded) : Wet'suwet'en chief can't cite Indigenous law to overturn criminal conviction, B.C. court rules
Indigenous Peoples framed as excluded from full legal recognition or protection
[omission], [cherry_picking]
news.com.au (Ally / Adversary) : ‘I stand by my work’: Bunurong elder Mark Brown denies misusing word ‘Anzac’ on merch …
Indigenous commemorative efforts are framed as adversarial to national traditions
[loaded_language] and [appeal_to_emotion]: Public backlash (boos) and emotionally charged product descriptions are juxtaposed to suggest conflict between Indigenous expression and Anzac tradition.
“‘I stand by my work and the message it carries.’”
news.com.au (Included / Excluded) : ‘I stand by my work’: Bunurong elder Mark Brown denies misusing word ‘Anzac’ on merch …
Indigenous cultural expression is portrayed as unwelcome or under scrutiny
[loaded_language] and [framing_by_emphasis]: The article opens with the image of Brown being booed during a Welcome to Country, immediately framing Indigenous public expression as contentious and met with hostility.
“An Indigenous elder whose Dawn Service Welcome to Country address was interrupted by boos has denied misusing the word ‘Anzac’ to sell a range of hoodies, shirts, trackies and sneakers.”
CBC (Included / Excluded) : Controversial academic Frances Widdowson arrested and fined for trespassing at University of Lethbridge
Indigenous cultural practices are portrayed as needing protection from mockery
The article includes the university's claim that Widdowson 'mocked Indigenous smudging ceremonies', which frames Indigenous students and staff as vulnerable to disrespect and in need of institutional protection, reinforcing their inclusion as a protected community.
“This includes videos intended to provoke University of Lethbridge community members, including one in which she mocked Indigenous smudging ceremonies (blowing marijuana smoke on her social media props).”
RNZ (Included / Excluded) : To sell or not to sell - fresh look needed over state asset sales
Excluding Māori perspectives on state-owned land and assets despite relevance
[omission]: The article references Pāmu/Landcorp but omits any mention of Māori interests or bicultural considerations in asset ownership, marginalizing a key stakeholder group.
The Globe and Mail (Included / Excluded) : B.C. Insider: What’s going on with Alberta oil?
Indigenous nations framed as legitimate, influential actors in energy decisions
[comprehensive_sourcing] and [proper_attribution]: The article highlights Indigenous leaders actively engaging investors and asserting legal and financial risks, positioning them as included and powerful stakeholders in pipeline decisions.
“Indigenous leaders from northern B.C. went to Calgary to pressure investors to shun a potential north coast pipeline route.”
The Guardian (Included / Excluded) : Evacuees from flooded remote Indigenous areas in NT housed in compound likened to ‘a prison …
Indigenous people framed as systematically excluded and marginalized in crisis response
[comprehensive_sourcing], [balanced_reporting]
“The federal minister for Indigenous Australians and Northern Territory senator Malarndirri McCarthy was also prevented from entering an evacuation site at Batchelor shortly after residents were relocated.”