US Government
Date Range
Score Range
BBC News (Legitimate / Illegitimate) : Florida lawmakers approve redistricting to help Republicans
Framed as engaging in partisan manipulation of democratic processes
[loaded_language] and [omission] together create a framing where redistricting is presented as overtly partisan, especially given the omission of DeSantis aide's admission of partisan intent, which would have reinforced legitimacy concerns
“Florida lawmakers have approved new congressional maps that could help Republicans maintain control of the thinly divided US House of Representatives in the midterm elections this year.”
ABC News Australia (Trustworthy / Corrupt) : US regulator orders review of ABC licence after Donald Trump criticises Jimmy Kimmel
Government regulatory action framed as politically motivated and corrupt
Linking FCC review directly to Trump’s demands without clarifying procedural independence implies corruption. Vague attribution delays naming the FCC, weakening institutional clarity and fostering suspicion of politicization.
“The agency that regulates US television has ordered an early review of the licence of US broadcaster ABC after President Donald Trump and his wife demanded it fire comedian Jimmy Kimmel.”
NZ Herald (Effective / Failing) : How to plan a massacre: AI bots told scientists how to make biological weapons
Government oversight is framed as inadequate, particularly under the Trump administration
Omission of current regulatory safeguards combined with the statement that the Trump administration 'dialled back oversight' implies systemic governmental failure in risk management.
“The Trump administration, resolved to lead the world in AI innovation, has dialled back oversight of the technology’s risk”
CBC (Effective / Failing) : A 'smoke-free generation' tobacco ban is coming to the U.K. Could it also happen in …
US policy change (raising smoking age) is framed as effective, offering evidence for broader generational bans
[comprehensive_sourcing]
“One study by Yale University researchers, published in December 2024, projected the move would avert up to 526,000 premature deaths across the U.S. by 2100.”
The New York Times (Ally / Adversary) : Supreme Court Sides With Anti-Abortion Clinic in Fight Over Donor Records
State government (via attorney general) is framed as adversarial toward disfavored groups
[editorializing] with attributed quote implies hostility; state action is presented as targeting a specific ideological group
“Lawyers for the group argued in court filings that the attorney general had 'made no secret of his hostility toward pregnancy centers,'”
Sky News (Ally / Adversary) : US accuses Mexican governor Ruben Rocha Moya of working with El Chapo's sons
US portrayed as assertive enforcer against foreign corruption
The article emphasizes U.S. accusations and framing of Mexican officials without balanced scrutiny, using strong language from U.S. officials that positions the U.S. as taking a firm, adversarial stance against Mexican political figures allegedly tied to cartels.
“The US has charged the governor of Mexico's Sinaloa state and nine other current or former officials with drug trafficking and weapons offences.”
BBC News (Safe / Threatened) : Fascination and wonder: How the US reacted to King Charles' visit
The US is portrayed as emotionally and socially vulnerable, needing royal pageantry to restore unity
[narrative_framing] and [appeal_to_emotion] frame the visit as a rare unifying moment in a fractured political landscape, implying the country is threatened by division.
“The United States declared independence from the British crown 250 years ago - but this week, it could not get enough of it.”
USA Today (Effective / Failing) : Kylie Kelce as 'Queen of Philly? 'Shapiro called out over coronation
Government officials are portrayed as unserious and engaging in trivial promotional stunts
Loaded language like 'caught some flack' and 'barrage of criticism' frames the governor’s lighthearted gesture as a misstep, implying incompetence or poor judgment in official conduct
“Pennsylvania Gov. Josh Shapiro caught some flack this week after collabing with Philly-area social superstar (and Eagles wife) Kylie Kelce.”
New York Post (Effective / Failing) : JD Vance rips Tim Walz for taking credit after Trump admin’s Minnesota fraud crackdown
Implies state-level government (via Walz) is failing in its duty, enabling fraud
Vance calls the lack of state cooperation a 'scandal' and hints at criminality, suggesting systemic failure. The article does not challenge this claim, allowing the framing of state government as negligent or complicit.
““the fact that they turned a blind eye towards it for so long is a scandal, [but] we’re also going to find out whether it was criminal,””
The New York Times (Legitimate / Illegitimate) : What We Got Right — and Wrong — in ‘Abundance’
framing federal and state governments as increasingly legitimate actors in advancing abundance ideology
[loaded_language]: The article uses approving language to describe governors and legislators adopting abundance rhetoric, implying growing legitimacy for technocratic, supply-side governance.
“You look at the fact that governors Kathy Hochul and JB Pritzker are talking about how their solutions to the energy crisis or the housing crisis must begin with a supply-side policy — that tells me that “abundance” is not just a word that’s being bandied about.”